The New York Times reports:
For three straight weeks, Americans have been buying less gasoline than they did a year ago. Consumption is dropping at a rate not seen since drivers were waiting in gas lines back in the early 1980’s. And people are turning to mass transit in record numbers in some cities.
Meanwhile, back home, a letter-writer to the AJC goes so far to not get it, he’d rather revert to hyperbole (name-calling, straw-man baiting):
Telecommuting, mass transit won’t workGov. Sonny Perdue’s request to close schools may have limited benefit for big-picture fuel issues, but to use it to parrot the old plea for increased mass transit and telecommuting ignores reality (”Misdirected energy,” Editorial, Sept. 27).
Even a fantasy-budgeted effort to widely increase mass transit infrastructure could never adequately serve Atlanta and surrounding counties. Atlanta doesn’t have localized hubs of employment.
Those who reply “MARTA” to every transportation question will never understand that the day’s reward for many commuters is to decompress in the leather- and music-rich environment of their personal vehicle, which they worked hard to acquire.
Unlike those would-be society-shapers and editorial writers quick to suggest telecommuting, most of America’s work force does not spend their workday at a computer terminal.
BILL LENTZ, Cumming
So, just because he enjoys his car as a sort of decompression chamber means I should, too?
Atlanta has several hubs of employment: Downtown, Midtown, Perimeter/Dunwoody and Cumberland, just to name a few. The first two are well-served by transit, with a clear benefit to traffic congestion. Perimeter/Dunwoody, especially the Abernathy corridor, would see a benefit if trains didn’t just go south from that area. Cumberland’s office market is, meanwhle, severely limited by the lack of transit that serves the area.
Let’s get real about something, Billy. If a train to Cumming were built, you wouldn’t have to use it. I know that’s an amazing revelation to you. No one is going to force you to take it. But, assuming you take GA-400 south to work in the mornings, you would certainly benefit from that train. While the commuters choosing to take the train can ride their little decompression chambers, you can use yours. The difference is that all those people taking the train aren’t with you on the road. That means there’s more room for you on the road.
Update: Otis White also had a column printed in yesterday’s New York Times:
We’ve learned a lot about evacuating cities in recent days, much of it deeply troubling. But if the failures of New Orleans and the gridlock of Houston show anything, it’s that we urgently need a third way out of cities, something other than flying or driving. Fortunately, there is such a way: passenger rail.





Very good points. Atlanta is almost crippled by attitudes like Billy’s. Unfortunatly, I think his opinion is in the majority. People do work hard for their yuppie-moblies. According to Jim Nalley (of Nalley Lexus, et al), “Atlanta has more dealers per capita than any city in America…” I’m inclined to believe him.
A few years ago, I read some statistics that Atlantans bought or leased more new cars than any other city in the country. Not per captia, mind you. Just more new cars, period (I’d site the article, but I can’t seem to it now…).
Its going to be hard to convince people to throw their support behind a usable mass transit system so long as they think that it means they can’t drive their $40,000 Lexsus SUV 30 miles everyday if they support a commuter rail.
I would think people like Billy would be a little more devious in their support, though. Dosen’t Billy realize, if he’d support mass transit, and it gets built, that there would be less cars between Cumming and Atlanta everyday? As you said, it doesn’t mean he has to use it. It could mean a very empty train for me to ride!
Dismissing a solution just because it doesn’t apply to everyone is a nucklehead thing to do.
Comment by Kick The Donkey — September 29, 2005 @ 7:58 am
Decompressing… so THAT’S what people are doing instead of paying attention to the road.
Comment by mingaling — September 29, 2005 @ 8:44 am
God, as a non driver/former Cumming resident, the lack of public transport up there is enough to make a man to mad things…
A train to Atlanta might have made things a bit more tolerable as opposed to one bus out in the morning and one bus back in the evening
Comment by Greg — September 29, 2005 @ 12:38 pm
The disgust over Sonny’s fuel folly has been wonderful to watch and fun participate in. It seems to me that the real issue is whether our state government will finally acknowledge that there is a metro area — a big fat urban metro area — smack in the middle of Georgia, and that he people who live in that big fat metro area have a right to expect big fat modern urban policies that deal with their needs. Sonny doesn’t understand that, which is why he won’t win re-election.
Comment by Ken Edelstein — September 29, 2005 @ 7:38 pm
Joe: Check out http://www.whatarewefor.com for a comment on your recent comment on the Beltline there. Couldn’t find your e-mail so I’m posting the message to your here
Comment by Ken Edelstein — September 29, 2005 @ 7:40 pm